The BMW E46 M3 is often hailed as one of the best M cars ever made. How does the modern F87 M2 compare to this legendary predecessor? Having owned both, I’ll share my personal experiences and insights into these two iconic BMW sports coupes.
First Impressions: Two Different Beasts
The debate between the BMW M2 and the E46 M3 is common amongst enthusiasts. Both boast similar weight and length, with the M2 being slightly wider. My initial impression of the M2 was that it felt entirely different from the E46 M3. It felt more akin to the F80 M3 platform, which I also previously owned. Driving the M2 home, it felt composed but underwhelming at normal speeds. I suspected its true potential lay dormant until pushed harder.
The Raw Appeal of the E46 M3
The E46 M3 delivers a raw, analog driving experience that is rare in modern cars. The steering is incredibly direct, providing a connected feel that few cars can replicate. The weighty steering, notchy shifter, and the iconic sound of the S54 engine contribute to its unique character. It’s remarkable how a car over two decades old can still deliver such an exhilarating driving experience, whether driven at speed or cruising leisurely. The E46 M3 embodies the essence of a pure driver’s car, a feeling the M2 strives to emulate.
The Modern Muscle of the F87 M2
Stepping into the F87 M2, the modern interior is immediately apparent. While often criticized for its minimalist design, it feels luxurious compared to the E46. Driving the M2 aggressively reveals its true nature. Unlike the E46 M3’s constant engagement, the M2 comes alive when pushed hard. The power difference is noticeable; with approximately 30 more horsepower and 100 more lb-ft of torque than the E46 M3, the similarly weighted M2 boasts a significant performance advantage. This difference translates to a more urgent and powerful acceleration experience.
Conclusion: Two Icons for Different Drivers
Both the Bm E46 M3 and the F87 M2 hold distinct places in my garage, each serving a different purpose. While not entirely comparable, the M2 is arguably the closest BMW has come to recreating the magic of the E46 M3. The E46 offers a pure, analog experience, while the M2 provides a modern interpretation of performance. Ultimately, the choice between these two exceptional cars depends on individual driving preferences and priorities. While the bm e46 m3 remains a legend, the F87 M2 successfully carries the torch of BMW performance into the modern era.
