Costco, the warehouse giant famed for bulk groceries and unbeatable deals, extends its savings beyond household essentials into the realm of car buying. Since 1989, the Costco Auto Program has been connecting its members with pre-negotiated prices on new and certified pre-owned vehicles. If the idea of car dealership haggling fills you with dread, the Costco car buying program might sound like a dream come true. But is the Costco car buy program good? Does it really save you money and simplify the car buying process, or is it just another marketing gimmick?
This in-depth review will explore the Costco Auto Program, dissecting its pros and cons to help you determine if leveraging your Costco membership for your next vehicle purchase is a smart move. We’ll delve into how the program works, the potential savings, the user experience, and compare it to other car buying methods.
What Exactly is the Costco Auto Program?
It’s crucial to understand that the Costco Auto Program isn’t about buying cars directly from Costco warehouses alongside your bulk paper towels. Instead, Costco acts as a facilitator, partnering with a network of over 3,000 franchised dealerships across the United States and Puerto Rico. These dealerships agree to offer Costco members pre-arranged, member-only pricing.
When you utilize the Costco Auto Program, you are essentially being connected to a designated contact at a participating dealership. This contact is trained to provide Costco members with a transparent and simplified buying experience, complete with pre-negotiated pricing. You can purchase new and certified pre-owned vehicles through the program, and participating dealerships can also handle your trade-in. Leasing a car or even buying an RV are also options available through this service.
The core promise of the Costco Auto Program is a less stressful and potentially more affordable car buying journey. Dealerships participating in the program are vetted for high customer service standards. Furthermore, Costco provides a Member Advocacy group to assist members who experience issues with a participating dealer, adding an extra layer of security and support.
Navigating the Costco Auto Program: Step-by-Step
If you’re intrigued by the prospect of buying your next car through Costco, it’s important to understand the process. You can’t simply walk into any dealership and flash your Costco card expecting a discount. Here’s a step-by-step guide to using the Costco Auto Program effectively:
Step 1: Begin Your Car Search Online
The first step is to visit the official Costco Auto Program website. Enter your ZIP code and select whether you are interested in a “New” or “Pre-Owned” vehicle to initiate your search. The website allows you to filter your search by various criteria, including model, year, make, and trim level. This online platform also provides resources for researching and comparing different vehicles, empowering you to make informed decisions.
For pre-owned vehicles, the process is slightly different. Instead of selecting a specific vehicle upfront, you’ll be browsing the inventories of participating dealerships in your vicinity. The underlying principle, however, remains the same: connecting you with Costco-approved dealerships offering member-exclusive deals.
After you’ve identified your desired vehicle (or a few options), you will be prompted to provide your personal information, including your name, contact details, and crucially, your Costco membership number. This verifies your eligibility for the program’s benefits.
Step 2: Connect with a Participating Dealership
Once you’ve specified your vehicle preferences, the Costco Auto Program website will present you with a list of approved dealerships that have your chosen car in stock or can order it. Select a dealership from this list that is convenient for you and initiate contact to schedule an appointment. It’s recommended to call ahead to ensure a smooth experience and confirm their participation in the Costco program.
Step 3: Visit the Dealership and Review Member Pricing
When you arrive at your scheduled appointment, you will be introduced to a designated Costco Authorized Dealer Contact. These individuals are specifically trained and authorized to work with Costco members. They will present you with your Costco Member-Only Price Sheet. This sheet details the prearranged price for the vehicle you’re interested in, a price negotiated in advance by Costco.
It’s important to note that reviewing the Costco Member-Only Price Sheet does not obligate you to purchase the vehicle. This step is designed to provide you with the transparent pricing information you need to make an informed decision. To access this exclusive pricing and experience the program’s benefits, following these steps is essential.
Financing Your Purchase
Remember, even when utilizing the Costco Auto Program, securing financing is a separate step, unless you plan to pay for your vehicle in cash. The Costco Auto Program focuses on simplifying the purchase price negotiation, not necessarily on auto loans. However, for those seeking financing, exploring options and comparing rates is always advisable. Online marketplaces can be valuable tools for comparing auto loan offers from multiple lenders, potentially saving you money on interest.
Weighing the Pros and Cons: Is the Costco Auto Program Worth It?
To truly answer the question “is the Costco car buy program good?”, it’s essential to analyze the advantages and disadvantages. The Costco Auto Program offers compelling benefits, but it’s not without its limitations. Carefully consider these pros and cons in light of your individual car buying needs and preferences:
Advantages of the Costco Auto Program
-
Simplified, Streamlined Experience: One of the most significant advantages is the streamlined car buying process. The pre-negotiated pricing means you bypass lengthy and often stressful price haggling. The Costco Authorized Dealer Contact should have your Member-Only Price Sheet ready, making the price discussion straightforward and efficient. This can save you considerable time and emotional energy at the dealership.
-
Helpful Online Resources: The Costco Auto Program website provides valuable online tools to aid your car buying journey. You can compare specifications and features of up to three vehicles side-by-side. Access to car reviews and a car finance calculator further empowers you to research and plan effectively before even stepping into a dealership.
-
Enhanced Customer Service Standards: Costco places a strong emphasis on customer service, and this extends to its Auto Program. Participating dealerships and their Authorized Dealer Contacts are expected to uphold Costco’s high standards. Costco even employs “secret shoppers” to periodically assess and ensure customer service quality within the program.
-
Exclusive Member Deals and Incentives: While Costco doesn’t publicly disclose average savings figures, they do highlight limited-time specials and manufacturer incentives available exclusively to Costco members through the program. These exclusive deals can potentially translate to significant savings on your vehicle purchase.
-
Post-Purchase Discounts: The benefits of the Costco Auto Program extend beyond just the initial car purchase. Members can also enjoy savings of up to 15% on car parts, service, and accessories at participating service centers. This ongoing discount can add value throughout your vehicle ownership experience.
Disadvantages of the Costco Auto Program
-
Costco Membership Requirement: A fundamental requirement is a Costco membership. If you’re not already a member, you’ll need to purchase a membership to use the program. A Gold Star membership is $60 annually, and an Executive membership costs $120 per year. You need to factor in this membership cost when evaluating potential savings.
-
Lack of Upfront Pricing Transparency: While the program offers pre-negotiated prices, you don’t get to see these prices online upfront. You must go through the process of selecting a vehicle, contacting a dealership, and visiting them to view the Costco Member-Only Price Sheet. This lack of initial price transparency might be a drawback for some buyers who prefer to compare prices online before committing to a dealership visit.
-
Limited Dealership Network: Not all dealerships participate in the Costco Auto Program. Costco has a selective vetting process, and only dealerships meeting their criteria are included. Furthermore, even at a participating dealership, you need to work with their designated Authorized Dealer Contact. This can sometimes lead to delays if the contact is unavailable.
-
Not Universal Vehicle Availability: While a wide range of vehicles are available through the program, you won’t find every single make, model, and trim level. Availability depends on the inventory and participation of dealerships in your local area. If you have a very specific or niche vehicle in mind, it might not be available through the Costco program.
-
Potential for Add-on Pressure: Despite the pre-negotiated vehicle price, dealerships may still attempt to sell you add-ons such as extended warranties or appearance packages. While the core vehicle price is set, you may still need to be assertive in declining unwanted extras to maintain your budget and avoid upselling. This means some level of negotiation might still be necessary.
Exploring Alternatives to the Costco Auto Program
Buying a vehicle is a major financial decision. Exploring different approaches to car buying is prudent to ensure you find the method that best suits your comfort level and financial goals. If the Costco Auto Program doesn’t seem like the perfect fit, consider these alternatives:
Independent Negotiation
For those who enjoy the art of negotiation or are confident in their haggling skills, negotiating directly with dealerships can be a viable alternative. By contacting multiple dealerships, obtaining quotes, and being prepared to walk away, you might be able to secure a price that is comparable to or even better than the Costco pre-negotiated price. This approach offers maximum flexibility in choosing dealerships and vehicles, but it does require time, effort, and negotiation skills.
Car Brokers
Car brokers act as professional car buyers who work on your behalf. They leverage their industry knowledge and dealer connections to find you the best possible deals and handle the negotiation process for you. While brokers charge a fee for their services, the time saved and potential savings they can secure might make it a worthwhile option for some buyers. It’s essential to research broker fees and compare them to potential savings to determine if this route is financially advantageous.
Competitor Car Buying Programs
The Costco Auto Program is not the only car buying service available. TrueCar is a well-known competitor that offers a similar service and is accessible to everyone, not just members of a specific club. TrueCar allows you to see price quotes from dealerships in your area and, in some cases, even complete the car purchase online.
AAA also offers an Auto Buying Program for its members, similar to Costco’s. AAA goes a step further by providing its own auto loans and car insurance options, creating a more comprehensive suite of services. Navy Federal Credit Union, partnering with TrueCar, offers a car buying service exclusively for its members, combining member-only pricing with the potential for financing through Navy Federal. Exploring these competitor programs can provide you with more options and potentially better suit your specific needs.
Final Verdict: Is the Costco Car Buy Program Good?
So, coming back to the original question: is the Costco car buy program good? The answer, like many things, is nuanced. For many Costco members, the answer is yes. The program offers genuine benefits, particularly for those who dislike haggling and value a streamlined, transparent car buying experience. The pre-negotiated pricing, enhanced customer service, and potential for exclusive deals are all compelling advantages.
However, it’s not a universally perfect solution. The Costco membership requirement, lack of upfront pricing visibility, and potential limitations in vehicle availability are factors to consider. You might still encounter pressure for add-ons, and if you are a skilled negotiator, you might be able to achieve similar or better deals independently.
Ultimately, the “goodness” of the Costco car buy program depends on your individual circumstances and preferences. If you are a Costco member, value convenience and a hassle-free experience, and are comfortable with the program’s structure, it’s definitely worth exploring. However, it’s always wise to compare the Costco offer with other options, such as negotiating independently or using competitor programs, to ensure you are making the most informed and financially sound car buying decision.
Get Started
