Maintaining a vibrant, green lawn is a common aspiration for homeowners. However, achieving a picture-perfect turf requires more than just desire; it demands a strategic lawn maintenance schedule and a well-planned lawn fertilizer schedule, with the right products applied at the optimal times throughout the year. The Best Diy Lawn Care Program simplifies this process, eliminating the guesswork by delivering customized lawn care plans directly to your doorstep. These subscription services provide not only essential treatments but also options to enhance soil health, repair damage, and manage pests effectively. For homeowners seeking to take control of their lawn care, understanding the leading DIY lawn care subscription services is the first step towards finding the ideal program for their specific needs.
At-a-Glance Comparison of DIY Lawn Care Programs
| Feature | Sunday Lawn Care | DoMyOwn Turf Box | Lawnbright | Lawn Serv |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Cost | $109 per year | Varies by location | $140 per year | $39 per month |
| Shipment Frequency | Seasonally | Monthly | Every 6 to 8 weeks | Monthly |
| Ingredient Type | Natural, Plant-Derived | Synthetic | Natural, Plant-Derived | Natural, Plant-Derived; Synthetic options |
| Herbicide Type | Post-Emergent | Pre-Emergent | Pre-Emergent | Pre & Post-Emergent |
| Product Type | Liquid | Granular | Liquid | Liquid & Granular |
| Pests Treated | Ants, Mosquitoes, Ticks, Grubs, Spiders | Ants, Mosquitoes, Ticks, Grubs, Spiders, Wasps, Hornets | Mosquitoes, Ticks | Mosquitoes, Ticks |
Top DIY Lawn Care Program Picks: Detailed Reviews
The following DIY lawn care programs have been selected based on a comprehensive evaluation of product offerings, nationwide shipping availability, packaging, sustainability efforts, environmental impact, program costs, and the variety of supplementary products offered. These programs stand out as leaders in the DIY lawn care market, providing homeowners with effective and convenient solutions for achieving a healthy and beautiful lawn.
Best Overall DIY Lawn Care Program
Sunday Lawn Care
Pros:
- Comprehensive and Customized Lawn Plan: Sunday Lawn Care excels in creating highly personalized lawn care plans. Their process begins with an in-depth survey that gathers crucial information about your lawn’s specific conditions, including climate, geographic location, size, and current health. This detailed approach ensures that the program is tailored to the unique needs of your lawn.
- Transparent Sustainability and Ethical Business Practices: Sunday distinguishes itself with a strong commitment to sustainability. They are transparent about their business practices and actively prioritize environmental responsibility. This includes using eco-friendly packaging and sourcing sustainable ingredients for their products.
- Location-Based Plant and Tree Suggestions: Beyond lawn care, Sunday offers valuable, location-specific recommendations for plants and trees. This feature helps homeowners make informed decisions about landscaping, ensuring they choose plants that thrive in their particular USDA growing zone.
- Sustainable and High-Quality Grass Seed: Sunday provides A-LIST approved grass seed, recognized for its sustainability and superior quality. This ensures that customers are using grass seed that is not only effective but also environmentally responsible.
- Commitment to Environmental Stewardship: As a member of “1% for the Planet,” Sunday demonstrates a tangible commitment to environmental solutions. This membership signifies their dedication to contributing a portion of their sales to environmental causes, further reinforcing their eco-conscious approach.
Cons:
- Limited Product Usage Instructions: Some users have noted that the product usage instructions provided by Sunday can be somewhat minimal. This could be a drawback for those who are new to DIY lawn care and prefer more detailed guidance on application techniques and schedules.
Why Sunday Lawn Care is the Best Overall:
Sunday Lawn Care’s nationwide reach, covering all 50 states and Washington, D.C., underscores its position as a leading DIY lawn care program. Its strength lies in the comprehensive and user-friendly lawn care plans, complemented by A-LIST approved grass seed, location-specific plant suggestions, and a deep-rooted commitment to sustainability.
The journey with Sunday begins with a detailed online survey, probing into factors like climate, location, and the lawn’s size and condition. The initial shipment includes a soil test kit, a critical component that allows Sunday to analyze your soil’s pH levels and formulate a truly customized treatment plan. For those looking to enhance their lawn density, Sunday also offers grass seed, seamlessly integrated into the personalized plan for overseeding. Furthermore, customers have the option to purchase plants – including perennials, trees, and shrubs – specifically recommended for their USDA growing zone. Sunday goes a step further by clearly labeling plants unsuitable for the customer’s climate, ensuring informed purchasing decisions, and ships plants at the optimal planting time for each region.
Sunday’s subscription boxes are dispatched seasonally, with the exact number of shipments adapting to the local growing season’s duration. Customers might receive anywhere from two to five shipments annually, from the season’s commencement to its conclusion. Starting a Sunday program mid-season is also a viable option. The product variety and shipment frequency are also plan-dependent. Beyond basic fertilization, Sunday’s product range extends to pest control, post-emergent weed treatments, pet damage repair, and solutions for heat-stressed lawns – essentially, everything a homeowner might need for a pristine lawn. While Sunday’s product coverage is generous for most homeowners, at 13,500 square feet, it may be insufficient for larger properties. Another point to consider is the conciseness of the provided instructions, which some users might find lacking in detail. This is important, as unclear instructions could potentially lead to application errors, affecting the treatment’s effectiveness.
In an era of increasing environmental awareness, Sunday Lawn Care allows customers to maintain a beautiful lawn while minimizing environmental impact. Their products are formulated with natural, plant-based ingredients and packaged with 30 percent post-consumer recycled materials, alongside transparent recycling guidelines. Sunday further publishes an annual sustainability report, detailing their environmental initiatives, and exclusively uses grass seed from A-LIST, a non-profit advocating for sustainable turfgrass varieties. Sunday’s membership in 1% for the Planet further cements its commitment to environmental responsibility.
Sunday Lawn Care Specs:
- Cost: Starting at $109 per year
- Shipment frequency: Seasonally
- Ingredient type: Natural, plant-derived
- Herbicide type: Post-emergent
- Product type: Liquid
- Pests treated: Ants, mosquitoes, ticks, grubs, spiders
Sunday Lawn Care has been recognized as a Home Improvement Hero by BobVila.com in 2024. The Home Improvement Heroes award celebrates companies that demonstrate exceptional service and reliability for homeowners. BobVila.com’s editorial team rigorously evaluates companies based on criteria such as availability, expertise, service range, cost-effectiveness, customer feedback, guarantees, refund policies, and customer support. See the full list of honorees.
Best DIY Lawn Care Program for Weeds and Disease Control
DoMyOwn Turf Box
Pros:
- Comprehensive Weed and Disease Solutions: DoMyOwn Turf Box is particularly effective in addressing common lawn issues such as weeds, diseases, and pests. Their programs are designed to provide targeted solutions for these challenges, helping homeowners maintain a healthy and problem-free lawn.
- Extensive Range of Additional Lawn and Garden Products: Beyond their subscription boxes, DoMyOwn offers a wide selection of additional lawn and garden products. This extensive inventory allows customers to conveniently source all their lawn care needs from a single provider, from fertilizers to specialized tools.
- High Maximum Coverage Area: With a coverage limit of up to 20,000 square feet, DoMyOwn Turf Box caters to homeowners with larger lawns. This generous coverage area ensures that even those with expansive properties can benefit from their DIY lawn care solutions.
- Discount on Additional Products: Subscribers to DoMyOwn Turf Box enjoy a valuable 10 percent discount on any additional DoMyOwn products. This perk provides ongoing savings for customers who regularly purchase lawn care supplies, making it a cost-effective choice for comprehensive lawn maintenance.
Cons:
- Fertilizer Not Included in Custom Plan: A notable limitation of DoMyOwn Turf Box is that fertilizer is not automatically included as part of their custom lawn care plans. Customers needing fertilization will need to purchase these products separately, which may require additional planning and expense.
Why DoMyOwn Turf Box Excels in Weed and Disease Control:
DoMyOwn Turf Box stands out for its affordable DIY solutions to prevalent lawn problems, notably fungus, weeds, and pests, with treatment capacities reaching up to 20,000 square feet. Subscribers also benefit from a 10 percent discount on a broad spectrum of additional lawn care products, enhancing its value proposition.
DoMyOwn Turf Box simplifies the process of diagnosing and treating common lawn ailments, including weeds, diseases, and pests. Customers begin with a straightforward diagnostic test, specifying their location and grass type (understanding your grass type is crucial). Based on this, DoMyOwn Turf Box crafts a bespoke program, shipping products precisely when they need to be applied, effectively removing any guesswork. Customers can opt for plans focusing on DIY lawn weed control, disease management, or a combined package addressing both, ensuring they receive only the treatments their lawn truly requires. Homeowners with larger properties will appreciate DoMyOwn Turf Box’s substantial 20,000 square foot coverage limit, which is notably generous among DIY lawn care programs.
While DoMyOwn’s website offers a comprehensive range of fertilizers, pre-emergent herbicides, fungicides, and pest control for issues like grubs, ants, ticks, and mosquitoes, these are not part of the standard subscription box. However, they are readily available for purchase as needed, and subscription box customers receive a 10 percent discount on these supplementary lawn care products.
DoMyOwn Turf Box Specs:
- Cost: Varies by location
- Shipment frequency: Monthly
- Ingredient type: Synthetic
- Herbicide type: Pre-emergent
- Product type: Granular
- Pests treated: Ants, mosquitoes, ticks, grubs, spiders, wasps, hornets
Best DIY Lawn Care Program for Customer Support
Lawnbright
Pros:
- In-depth Consultations with Lawn Care Professionals: Lawnbright distinguishes itself by offering direct access to lawn care professionals for in-depth consultations. This personalized support system allows customers to discuss specific lawn concerns, receive expert advice, and tailor their lawn care approach with professional guidance.
- Real-Time Lawn Care Instructions via Text Message: Lawnbright provides real-time support through text message instructions. This innovative approach ensures that customers receive timely guidance and reminders directly on their mobile devices, making lawn care management convenient and accessible.
- Eco-Conscious Philanthropy: Lawnbright demonstrates a commitment to environmental responsibility by donating a percentage of each sale to an eco-friendly nonprofit organization. This philanthropic aspect appeals to environmentally conscious consumers who want their purchases to support broader ecological initiatives.
Cons:
- Limited Standard Plan Coverage for Larger Lawns: Lawnbright’s standard plans are designed for lawns up to 10,000 square feet. Homeowners with larger lawns may find that the standard plans are insufficient, requiring them to opt for custom quotes that may be more expensive.
Why Lawnbright Excels in Customer Support:
Lawnbright is an environmentally conscious service providing plant-based, user-friendly lawn care products devoid of harsh chemicals. It is particularly noted for its exceptional customer support, including professional consultations and real-time text message instructions and alerts.
Lawnbright tailors DIY lawn treatments to each customer’s specific lawn care needs, considering location, lawn size, and soil test results. Their product range includes weed control, pet spot treatments, mosquito and tick management, fertilizers, soil enhancers, and more. Lawnbright’s “Ingredient Promise” guarantees that all products are formulated with natural ingredients like cedar oil, kelp, and corn gluten meal, ensuring they are free from harsh chemicals that could harm people and the environment. Customers can choose from three plan tiers based on lawn size, though it’s important to note that standard plans are capped at 10,000 square feet; larger properties will require a custom, potentially pricier quote. Treatments are scheduled for delivery every 6 to 8 weeks, with automatic pauses during regional dormant months.
A key differentiator for Lawnbright is its outstanding customer support. Customers with questions or needing extra assistance can access consultations with the company’s Turf Team for personalized guidance. Lawnbright also offers complimentary Turf Alerts—text messages delivering valuable information on weather conditions and lawn care tips, such as fertilizing schedules and watering advice. This support is especially beneficial for those new to DIY lawn care, offering reassurance and practical help. While specific details about these support services are somewhat limited online, interested customers can contact Lawnbright for more information before subscribing.
Lawnbright’s commitment to sustainability is further evidenced by their donations to Non Toxic Communities, a non-profit aiding communities in reducing toxic chemicals in their environment. This dedication resonates with homeowners who prioritize environmental stewardship.
Lawnbright Specs:
- Cost: Starting at $140 per year
- Shipment frequency: Every 6 to 8 weeks
- Ingredient type: Natural, plant-derived
- Herbicide type: Pre-emergent
- Product type: Liquid
- Pests treated: Mosquitoes, ticks
Also Consider: Weather-Optimized DIY Lawn Care
Lawn Serv
Pros:
- Customized Monthly Boxes Based on Local Weather: Lawn Serv excels in tailoring its DIY lawn care boxes to the specific weather conditions of each customer’s location. By analyzing local weather data, Lawn Serv optimizes each monthly shipment to include the products most relevant and effective for the prevailing climate and seasonal changes.
- Availability of Both Pre-Emergent and Post-Emergent Herbicides: Lawn Serv offers both pre-emergent and post-emergent herbicides, providing homeowners with comprehensive weed control solutions. This dual approach allows for tackling weeds at all stages of growth, ensuring a consistently weed-free lawn throughout the year.
Cons:
- Limited Stock in Online Shop: Lawn Serv’s online store, while offering a variety of lawn care products and tools, sometimes suffers from limited stock. This can be inconvenient for customers looking to purchase additional items or replacements outside of their subscription boxes.
- Synthetic Products in Some Plans: While Lawn Serv offers natural and mostly natural plans, some of their plans, particularly the Traditional plan, include synthetic products. Customers seeking exclusively natural lawn care solutions need to carefully choose their plan to avoid synthetic ingredients.
Why Lawn Serv is a Strong Contender:
Lawn Serv employs a science-driven approach to deliver personalized DIY lawn care packages. By analyzing local weather data, they precisely tailor each monthly shipment to meet the specific needs of a customer’s lawn. Lawn Serv provides three plan options: Traditional (primarily synthetic products), Mostly Natural (synthetic weed control with mostly natural products), and All Natural (entirely natural, no weed control). The Mostly Natural and All Natural plans are slightly more expensive than the Traditional plan but remain among the most affordable DIY lawn care services. Lawn Serv packages are delivered monthly, with flexible options to pause, cancel, or customize deliveries. They also offer seasonal subscriptions, pausing shipments during non-growing periods based on location.
Beyond subscription boxes, Lawn Serv offers a range of products and tools on their website, although stock may be somewhat limited. Notably, their offering of both pre-emergent and post-emergent herbicides allows homeowners to effectively combat weeds throughout the year, regardless of their growth stage.
Lawn Serv Specs:
- Cost: Starting at $39 per month
- Shipment frequency: Monthly
- Ingredient type: Natural, plant-derived; synthetic (plan-dependent)
- Herbicide type: Pre and Post-Emergent
- Product type: Liquid and granular
- Pests treated: Mosquitoes, ticks
Our Verdict: Choosing the Best DIY Lawn Care Program
For a comprehensive DIY lawn treatment experience, encompassing DIY weed control, environmentally conscious DIY lawn care chemicals, and extensive customizable options, Sunday Lawn Care emerges as the top recommendation for the best lawn care subscription service. Its commitment to customization, sustainability, and ease of use makes it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking a holistic lawn care solution. For targeted weed and disease management, DoMyOwn Turf Box earns the distinction of “Best for Weeds and Disease,” offering effective DIY solutions for common lawn problems at a competitive price.
How We Evaluated the Best DIY Lawn Care Programs
Selecting the top DIY lawn care programs involved a thorough evaluation of numerous options, focusing on services that deliver some of the best lawn care products directly to consumers. Key factors considered included cost, the breadth of product and plan offerings, and shipment frequency. Environmental impact was a critical consideration, evaluating both manufacturing and packaging processes, as well as product ingredients, with a preference for companies offering more plant-based products for environmental and ethical reasons. Additional factors included the availability of pest control and disease solutions, and the range of supplementary products like plants and grass seed.
Key Considerations When Choosing a DIY Lawn Care Program
Before committing to a DIY lawn care program, several factors warrant careful consideration. While establishing a lawn care schedule is essential for a healthy lawn, each program offers distinct solutions and add-ons. Understanding the nuances of ingredient types (organic, plant-based, or animal-based), shipment frequency, packaging, and cost is crucial for making an informed decision. Evaluating these aspects upfront will empower customers to select the DIY lawn care program that best aligns with their lawn’s needs and personal preferences.
Subscription Plan Details and Cost Analysis
When comparing DIY lawn care subscriptions, understanding shipment frequency is crucial for establishing an effective lawn care schedule. Many DIY lawn care plans are season-based, with product shipments timed accordingly, while some services offer monthly deliveries during the active growing season.
The cost of DIY lawn care products varies widely depending on the plan type, included products, and payment structure (upfront annual payment versus monthly installments). It’s important to compare the overall value proposition of different programs in relation to their pricing.
Ingredient and Product Composition: What’s in Your Lawn Care?
Ingredient lists in DIY lawn treatment products can vary significantly. Understanding the composition of these products is vital for aligning with personal needs and values.
-
Plant-Derived vs. Animal-Derived Ingredients: Fertilizers can utilize both animal and plant-derived ingredients, each providing essential nutrients. Many common fertilizers combine both types.
- Animal-based fertilizers contain components like bone meal, blood meal, fish meal, and animal waste such as manure. These often have a strong odor, and some, especially manure, can cause root burn due to high nitrogen content. Animal waste-based ingredients are also high in salt, which can harm beneficial soil microbes, making them less environmentally friendly than plant-based alternatives. Ethical concerns regarding animal rights may also influence preferences against animal-derived ingredients.
- Plant-based ingredients, including corn gluten, soybean meal, and molasses, generally have less odor and offer a more sustainable nutrient source as they break down slowly over time.
-
Liquid vs. Granular Products: The choice between liquid and granular products impacts the lawn fertilizer schedule, especially for new versus established lawns.
- Granular fertilizers are dry pellets or sand-like substances, often slow-release, gradually releasing nutrients. Quick-release granular options also exist. Slow-release types typically require only one application per season.
- Liquid fertilizers are concentrates diluted with water before application, available in liquid or soluble forms. Mostly quick-release, they provide immediate nutrients but necessitate reapplication.
-
Pre-Emergent vs. Post-Emergent Herbicides: Herbicides, designed to eliminate unwanted vegetation like weeds, are categorized as pre-emergent and post-emergent. Pre-emergent herbicides prevent weed growth by targeting germinating weed seeds. Post-emergent herbicides kill existing weeds but do not prevent new seed germination. The effectiveness of each type depends on lawn conditions and environmental factors like sunlight and rainfall.
Addressing Lawn Disease: Treatment and Prevention
While preventative healthy lawn care practices and proper lawn nutrition are key to minimizing disease, ensuring a DIY lawn care program offers disease treatment options is prudent.
Lawn diseases can arise from various factors, including improper mowing, overwatering, and incorrect fertilizer use. Common signs include brown or yellow patches, mushroom growth, or snow mold. Prompt treatment is crucial to avoid the cost of a new lawn.
Pest Control Product Availability: Managing Lawn Pests
Turf pests are a common challenge. Therefore, assessing the pest control product offerings of a lawn care subscription service is important. Common turf pests include grubs, chinch bugs, sod webworms, armyworms, and cutworms. Controlling nuisance insects like mosquitoes, ticks, and ants may also be a priority.
Many lawn care subscriptions include pest control options. Knowing that a program provides the necessary products for pest management is a significant factor in choosing the right DIY solution.
Sustainability in Products and Packaging: Environmental Responsibility
The convenience of DIY lawn care programs often comes with single-use plastic packaging. For environmentally conscious customers, understanding a company’s sustainability practices is crucial. This includes assessing the use of recycled or sustainably sourced materials, and the recyclability of packaging.
Additionally, fertilizer manufacturing can contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. Evaluating a company’s environmental policies regarding manufacturing, packaging, and shipping practices is important for those prioritizing sustainability.
Availability of Additional Products: One-Stop Lawn Care Shopping
Beyond core lawn care products, access to supplemental products can be a significant advantage. This may include lawn care equipment, hand tools, mowers, garden tools, and plants like perennials, trees, and shrubs, offering a convenient one-stop shopping experience.
Before You Choose a DIY Lawn Care Program: Is DIY Right for You?
While DIY lawn care programs aim to simplify lawn maintenance, they may not suit everyone. Time commitment is a significant factor; even with simplified programs, regular lawn care demands consistent time investment, which may be challenging due to time constraints or mobility limitations. In such cases, hiring professional lawn care services might be a more practical solution, often including services like weeding and hedge trimming. Furthermore, some essential lawn care services, such as annual lawn aeration (averaging $140 in cost), are typically not included in DIY programs.
Diagnosing and resolving complex lawn issues like pests, diseases, heat damage, or neglect can be challenging. Similar symptoms across various problems (brown spots, yellow spots, bare patches) can complicate diagnosis and treatment. In severe cases, overseeding, reseeding, or sod replacement (considering sod vs. seed cost) might be necessary, potentially requiring professional lawn care expertise.
Finally, gardeners who prefer homemade fertilizers might find subscription programs less appealing, as fertilizer is central to these services.
Cost-Effectiveness of DIY Lawn Care Programs
The average cost of the best DIY lawn care program ranges from $39 per month to $140 per year, potentially increasing to $200 or more with added products like grass seed and herbicides. It’s important to remember that lawn care is seasonal, and monthly subscriptions typically don’t ship during dormant winter months. A typical annual program covers spring, summer, and fall, providing treatments for spring growth, active growing season maintenance, and fall preparation.
Comparing costs, DIY lawn care programs are generally more affordable than professional lawn care services. The national average lawn care service cost per visit is around $124 (ranging from $48 to $206), varying with yard size and services. Monthly professional service during the growing season can average $124 per visit for 4 to 6 months. However, services like Sunday Lawn Care vs. TruGreen need to be evaluated considering that professional services may include maintenance like mowing and edging, which DIY programs require homeowners to handle themselves.
Advantages of Choosing a DIY Lawn Care Program
Achieving a lush, healthy lawn is a source of pride for many homeowners, enhancing curb appeal and providing personal satisfaction. Beyond aesthetics, DIY lawn care programs offer several key advantages:
- Eliminates Guesswork: No more confusion in store aisles trying to select the right products.
- Reduces Application Errors: Timely product delivery minimizes the risk of incorrect product application or timing, preventing potential lawn damage.
- Ingredient Control: DIY programs offer transparency and control over product ingredients, especially crucial for those seeking organic or non-chloride solutions not always available with professional services.
- Cost Savings: DIY lawn care is typically significantly more affordable than professional services.
- Outdoor Activity and Exercise: DIY lawn care provides opportunities for fresh air and physical activity.
FAQs: Common Questions About DIY Lawn Care
Many homeowners have similar questions regarding DIY lawn care. Here are answers to some frequently asked questions.
Q. What is the best mowing pattern?
The spiral pattern is considered optimal: start at the perimeter and mow inwards in a spiral. Long stripes are also efficient and widely used, achieved by mowing along the length, making a U-turn, and mowing back in the opposite direction to create stripes.
Q. What is the 1/3 mowing rule?
The 1/3 rule advises cutting only the top third of the grass blade length during mowing. This practice maintains lawn health and prevents growth stunting from excessively short cuts.
Q. When should I test my soil?
The University of Maine recommends soil testing well before the growing season, ideally in early spring after the last frost or in fall before the first frost. Lab soil tests typically take at least 3 weeks for results.
Q. Is it better to fertilize before or after mowing?
For optimal lawn fertilizer application, fertilize after mowing and raking. This allows fertilizer to reach the soil more easily.
Q. Should I water my lawn 2 or 3 times a week?
Watering lawns two to three times per week is generally sufficient, avoiding overwatering. Adjust frequency based on rainfall and temperature extremes.
Q. What is the best homemade fertilizer for lawns?
Compost tea is a highly effective homemade lawn fertilizer. It’s a liquid mixture of solid compost and sometimes includes liquid concentrates like fish fertilizer or seaweed.
Bob Vila and Recurrent Ventures prioritize conservation and sustainability. While the discussed lawn care solutions are effective, not all are strictly organic or sustainable. BobVila.com encourages readers to make informed decisions about home and property maintenance, choosing solutions that minimize negative impacts on the environment and its inhabitants.
Save Energy While Staying Cozy with Efficient Space Heaters
Modern energy-efficient space heaters are designed to warm individual rooms, allowing users to avoid heating unoccupied areas of their homes. Extensive testing has identified the top-performing space heaters on the market.
DISCOVER OUR TOP PICKS FOR ENERGY-EFFICIENT SPACE HEATERS
